Upgrading App Server Option Missing

Hello,

I am testing an upgrade from 10.1.400 to 10.2.200. I was able to install the update and get my database upgraded without issue. I got my ssl cert taken care of and when wanting to upgrade my existing app server the information is not populating and just giving me a blank config:

Should I just create a new app server at this point? I have already tried deleting everything out of the admin console and adding it again to see if I can get the prompt shown in the documentation I have linked below without any luck:

I did a server reboot and went into the IIS manager to make sure that everything was showing in my app pools and I got the app server to pop up when clicking browse.

Being an IT guy I should have followed my own advice of “Did you reboot your computer yet?”